Notice stating that an image has been removed due to a DMCA notice: Image
removed
due to
DMCA notice

Mogul Press – using fraud to silence criticism of their deceptive business practices

27 January 2024

2 Comments

I’ve written previously about a business called Mogul Press, which spams people on social media from fake profiles, often with stolen photos of real people. They claim to be a “PR agency” but their business appears to actually involve charging for paid placements in low quality media.

UPDATE 17 February 2024 – Mogul Press and its associates appear to be in the business of filing fraudulent copyright takedowns. We wrote about it here.

Mogul Press didn’t much like our article. At that point I thought they had several options:

  • Change their business practices: stop spamming people, stop using fake profiles, and be honest about what their business actually is.
  • Given they claim to be an “award-winning public relations and communications agency” they could communicate to the world why my article was inaccurate or unfair.
  • Threaten legal proceedings – although given that my claims were factual, this would always be challenging.

What I didn’t appreciate was that they had a fourth option – fraud.

I received this from Google:

Notice of DMCA removal from Google Search Console sent to taxpolicy.org.uk: Google Search Console

Notice of DMCA removal from Google Search

To: Webmaster of https://www.taxpolicy.org.uk/,

Google has been notified, according to the terms of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), that some of the material found on your site allegedly infringes upon the copyrights of others. Although some of these URLs may not be available in our search results now, we are retaining these notices and will act on them if at some point in the future we do crawl these pages for inclusion in search results.

The notice that we received, with any personally identifying information removed, may be found on the website of Lumen, a third-party aggregator of legal complaint notices, at http://www.chillingeffects.org/notice.cgi?sID=15710816.

Please note that it may take several weeks for the notice to be posted on the above page.

What you can do next:

File a Counter Notice
If you feel that your sites or pages were mistakenly removed due to a DMCA request filed against you, Google can reinstate these materials into our search results upon receipt of a DMCA Counter Notification.

Speak to a lawyer
If you have legal questions about this notification, you may wish to speak to your own lawyer.

Here are the affected URL(s):

https://www.taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/11/23/mogul_press

It’s a “takedown notice” under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The idea is that a copyright owner can submit an online form to a service provider, e.g. Google complaining that an indexed page on the internet breaches its copyright. Google will then delist the page and notify its owner. If the owner disagrees there’s a copyright breach then they can file a “counter-notice“. The complainant then has a couple of weeks to begin an actual legal action for breach of copyright; if it doesn’t, the service provider restores access.

I assumed they’d complained about my use of images of their website. These are copyrighted, but I’m perfectly entitled to use them for purposes of comment/criticism under the US “fair use” doctrine. In theory, I could sue Mogul Press for filing a bad-faith takedown notice.

But I was wrong. We can now see copies of the actual complaints and they aren’t incorrect, or bad faith. They’re simply fraudulent:

DMCA copyright complaint submitted to Google by LMG Media Group dated 22 January 2024: DMCA (Copyright) Complaint to Google

SENDER
LMG Media Group
[Private]
AE
Sent on January 22, 2024
COUNTRY: AE

RECIPIENT
Google LLC
[Private]
Mountain View, CA, 94043, US

SUBMITTER
Google LLC

Re: Unknown

NOTICE TYPE:
DMCA

Copyright claim 1

KIND OF WORK:
Unspecified

DESCRIPTION
We would like to bring attention to a recently discovered link which is completely infringing our copyrighted texts and images, without any consent from us. The infringing link has clearly copied every single text and image, with little to no modification. This is a clear violation of both LMG Media Group and Google's Copyright policy. Therefore we would request immediate removal of this link from google search.

ORIGINAL URLS:
01. https://thetribunepost.com/mogul-press/

ALLEGEDLY INFRINGING URLS:
01. https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/11/23/shady_scam_mogul_press/

JURISDICTIONS
AE

The “tribunepost.com” link (archived version here) is just a direct copy of our article. Mogul Press created it (naturally breaching our copyright) and then filed a DMCA notice claiming that we’d copied them. This is, very obviously, just fraud.

It seems reasonably clear we’d have a claim for damages against Mogul Press under the DMCA. Google has taken legal action against similar fraudulent takedown requests in the past. Criminal offences may also have been committed.

Given the likelihood Mogul Press and its CEO, Nabeel Ahmad, are just scammers with no easily-traceable assets, it’s probably not worth spending time suing them. I’ll probably hurt them more financially by publishing this article – and that would be an entirely fair outcome.


Image by Lexein.

Footnotes

  1. I asked Mogul Press what they were up to, and they didn’t reply – so I think we can discard the possibility that someone else did this without telling Mogul Press ↩︎

2 responses to “Mogul Press – using fraud to silence criticism of their deceptive business practices”

  1. Eric avatar

    If you start a GoFundMe or similar campaign to mount a legal defense, I will donate to it, as I’m sure others would too.

  2. Alf avatar

    “just scammers with no easily-traceable assets” ?? – but the CEO of Mogul Press says he’s a “global trailblazer” who “built a million dollar company at the age of 22” !!

    https://nabeelahmad.com/press-media/

    – Can’t you just sue them for the laughs?
    Film it all as you go along – pretend your Esther Rantzen back in the day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *